Most people think of money as one thing.
A dollar is a dollar. The number in your banking app, the bill in your wallet, and the reserve balance a bank holds at the Federal Reserve all look like the same unit. They are not. They are different instruments on different balance sheets, and the difference between them is the single most useful idea for understanding why the monetary system behaves the way it does in a crisis, and why Bitcoin is a different kind of thing than anything the system has produced in fifty years.
Nik Bhatia’s Layered Money gives the idea a name and a diagram. Money is a pyramid. At the top sits a base asset that is nobody’s liability. Every layer beneath it is a promise to pay the layer above. The promises are useful, elastic, and fragile, in that order. Once you see the pyramid, you cannot read a headline about banks, central banks, or digital currencies the same way again.
The First Layer: Money That Is Nobody’s Promise
Start with a gold coin. When you hold it, you hold the thing itself. No one has to honor anything for it to be worth what it is worth. Bhatia calls this first-layer money. Its defining feature is the absence of counterparty risk: there is no issuer whose default can turn it into nothing.
For most of recorded history, first-layer money was metal. The Florentine florin of 1252 is Bhatia’s starting point, a gold coin of consistent weight that became the settlement unit of European trade for centuries. It worked because it was final. Delivering a florin ended the transaction. Nobody owed anybody anything afterward.
Finality is what the base layer provides and what every layer below it borrows.
The Second Layer: Promises to Pay
The Medici bankers did not move florins around Europe. They wrote bills of exchange, paper promises to pay coin at a later date in another city. A merchant in Bruges could accept a bill from Florence, redeem it locally, and never touch metal. Bhatia’s description of the arrangement is precise: the bill is second-layer money, and the bank sits between the layers, issuing a liability that promises first-layer money on demand.
Two things happened at once. Trade accelerated, because paper moves faster than gold. And risk entered the system, because a promise can be broken. Bhatia is careful to say that this was not a bankers’ trick imposed on the public. Merchants accepted bills because deferred settlement was worth the risk. In his words, the layers of money are not a construct of bankers but immanent in the human tendency to keep tabs with each other.
The second layer also introduced elasticity. Coins cannot be created from nothing. Bills can. A bank that holds one hundred florins can issue bills for more than one hundred, betting that not everyone redeems at once. That bet is the origin of fractional reserve banking, and it is also the origin of the bank run, which is nothing more than depositors climbing the pyramid to reach the layer above before it runs out.
The Third Layer and Below
Central banks turned the two-layer system into three. The Bank of England, chartered in 1694, issued notes that promised gold. Commercial banks then issued deposits that promised Bank of England notes. A depositor in London held third-layer money: a claim on a bank, which held a claim on the central bank, which held the gold.
Bhatia’s most important observation is about what governs this structure. The first layer disciplines everything beneath it. As long as notes are redeemable for gold, the Bank of England can only issue so many. As long as deposits are redeemable for notes, commercial banks can only lend so much. Remove the redemption, and the discipline goes with it.
That removal happened in stages. The Bank Restriction Act of 1797 suspended gold redemption during a panic and stayed in force for over two decades. The United States ended domestic gold redemption in 1933 and international redemption in 1971. Each step pushed the base asset further out of reach of ordinary holders, and each step loosened the constraint on how much of the lower layers could be created.
What the Pyramid Looks Like Today
Today the apex of the dollar pyramid is U.S. Treasuries. Bhatia is explicit: without gold, Treasuries stood alone as the only first-layer money. Federal Reserve liabilities, physical currency and the reserve balances banks hold at the Fed, are the second layer. Everything you can actually use, your checking balance, your money market fund, your PayPal balance, is third layer or lower. Base money is on the order of one quarter of the broad dollar supply; the rest is bank-created promises. Most dollars are not issued by the Federal Reserve. They are issued by banks, and they exist because someone borrowed.
The apex is itself a promise. A Treasury is a promise to pay dollars, which are Fed liabilities, and the Fed’s dominant asset is Treasuries. Since 1971 the dollar pyramid has had no first layer that is not a promise. The pyramid points at itself.
This is what Ammous means when he describes fiat as a system in which money and debt are the same thing. It is also why I want you holding this framework before you go anywhere near fiat mechanics: once you see that a bank deposit is a third-layer promise, the mechanics of how banks create it are no longer mysterious. They are just the issuance of a lower layer.
Where Bitcoin Fits
Bhatia’s book ends with a second pyramid. Bitcoin is a first-layer asset in the same sense gold was: it is nobody’s liability. Holding the private keys to an unspent output is holding the thing itself. There is no issuer whose balance sheet has to hold up for the asset to exist. Bhatia’s summary is that BTC is a neutral, counterparty-free money like gold that people trust as a form of final settlement.
The second layer is already forming on top of it. Lightning channels are promises to settle on chain, opened and closed with two base-layer transactions. Exchange balances are second-layer promises, which is exactly why the collapse of an exchange takes customer coins with it: the customer held a claim on the exchange, not the asset.
The framework does two things for a Bitcoin holder. It explains the risk hierarchy precisely: keys are first layer, a channel is second, a custodial balance is second too, with a counterparty you cannot audit. And it explains why Bitcoin is the first new base layer in half a century. Every other digital dollar, from stablecoins to whatever a central bank issues under the name digital currency, is a promise stacked on the existing pyramid. Bitcoin is a new apex, and the layers under it are being built in public.
“Bitcoin will take care of you if you take care of your bitcoin.”
— John Carvalho
Sources: Layered Money Ch.1–3, 5–6, 8 (Bhatia) | Broken Money Ch.7–9 (Alden) | The Bitcoin Standard Ch.4 (Ammous) | The Fiat Standard Ch.5–6 (Ammous)
What Is A.W. Block?
A.W. Block is a digital asset estate investigation and Bitcoin advisory firm. On the estate side, we support attorneys, probate administrators, and fiduciaries with asset identification, blockchain investigation, and court-ready documentation. On the advisory side, we work with individuals and institutions on Bitcoin custody, accumulation strategy, and education.
awblock.io
Found value? Share, subscribe, and/or send sats here: bc1qrlgzu0m94wdrsnxjg8qym7jtnudelgfypmjmaa
Around the Block is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.